Quote:
|
Originally Posted by glockmail
So are you denying that Judaism is a religion?
|
Huh? I don't care if the premise is a religion, a presidential speech or a hairdryer. For your "proof" to be true, it needs your premise to be true (in this particular case the contents of the Torah). Not merely to exist but to be true.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by glockmail
My proof is simply based on the same premise made by Mohamed with respect to Judaism.
|
I'm sure it is. It doesn't make it more correct. It just means Mohammed based it on the same premise.
Faith in itself is based on self-evident premises. If a faith diverges from another faith, it renders the other faith untrue on the instances where it diverts. There's nothing you can do logically to prove a faith more true than the other. Per definition, you will always base such an attempt on a self-evident premise. I.e. the truth of which is based on the truth of itself.